Showing posts sorted by relevance for query taqiyya. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query taqiyya. Sort by date Show all posts

Tuesday, May 05, 2015

A Taxonomy of Taqiyya

http://sanantoniobars.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/worm-bar-logo-250x250.jpg

Recently on Jihad Watch comments, a Muslim commenter (fatuously calling himself "Galen Muhammad") tried to school the regulars there on the Islamic concept of taqiyya (deception):

"Arabic (not Islamic) words, like taqiyya have been redefined by Islamaphobes [sic] to mean “lying to spread Islam” — a non-existing concept in Islam."

As I wrote at the time:

Galen Muhammad is technically correct about taqiyya—but it’s a distinction effectively without a difference. So, yes, we can say that taqiyya is deceit not directly to “spread Islam”—but rather to defend Islam against “enemies”. And what are these “enemies” doing that needs to be “defended” against? Why, those enemies are preventing Muslims from spreading Islam! Thus once again we see, here in encapsulated form, the reverse bully formula of Islam: Muslims aggress; the non-Muslim defends himself from the Muslim; the Muslim labels the non-Muslim’s defensive action as an “offense” against Islam which must be defended against. In our current era, this is playing out in an elaborately complex and diverse way, involving the mass migration of Muslims into the Camp of the Enemy (the Dar-al-Harb which in this context = the West), coupled with the Islamic precept that any individual or society that refuses to submit to Allah and His Prophet is, ipso facto, committing a casus belli (a declaration of war) against Islam—against which, again, in the Orwellian, Bizarro World, Allah-in-Wonderland logic of Islamic fanaticism, Muslims must “defend” themselves against to protect Islam.

* * * * *

But taqiyya isn't the only style of deceit in Islamic culture.  Not too long ago I stumbled on a handy list at the "Islam Exposed" blog—a veritable taxonomy of taqiyya—on a site I'd never seen before (I encourage the reader to go there, as they have reference citations for these terms):

Taqiyya (Shia) or Muda’rat (Sunni): tactical deceit for the purposes of spreading Islam.

Kitman: deceit by omission.

Tawriya: deceit by ambiguity.

Taysir: deceit through facilitation (not having to observe all the tenets of Sharia).

Darura: deceit through necessity (to engage in something “Haram” or forbidden).

And my favorite:

Muruna: the temporary suspension of Sharia in order that Muslim immigrants appear “moderate.”

* * * * *

As I wrote when I first heard of just one of these (tawriya, from a Raymond Ibrahim article on Jihad Watch), back in 2012:

Oh great, another term for us Infidels to learn from the linguistic jungle of the lexicon of Satan’s pedagogy of his minions. Everytime I learn a new Islamic term I feel the frisson of having uncovered a rock to glimpse yet another fleeting wriggle of some infernal venomous insect; or in a drunken funk chanced upon the toxic worm at the bottom of a bottle of taqiyya—er, I mean, tequila.

This tawriya seems to be not a separate type of deceit from taqiyya, but a categorical distinction: i.e., taqiyya is the category of the virtue and pragmatic efficacy of deceit in general, which may be crudely simplistic or artfully clever; while tawriya would be the methodology of how to do it — or at least one methodology. It resembles clever sophistry, whereas there are cruder ways to lie, as they used to say, “baldly”.

For example, if someone declares “I don’t have a penny in my pocket,” most listeners will assume the speaker has no money on him -- though he might have dollar bills, just literally no pennies.

The cruder, balder, more blatant form of lying about this would be to say simply, “I have no money”, meanwhile one’s pockets are bulging with 100-dollar bills. Many Muslims have shown themselves to be fully capable of doing this cruder form, and fully willing to do so -- and why not, when there are so many gullible Guilty White Westerns around them anxiously willing to give a Brown Person the benefit of the doubt?

The difference between the cruder form and the more artful form of tawriya would be the difference between what has been colorfully rendered as “lying through your teeth”, and the cleverer, more devilish (if not positively Satanic) form where the tongue becomes a cunning linguist of a snake to perform a perverse and abusive fellatio on its more or less unwilling victim (depending on his gullible naivety and desperation to believe in the wiles of the Moderate Muslim...).

* * * * *

I’d thought about kitman too when I first read Ibrahim’s essay mentioned above. There might be, in the Muslim mind and culture, a subtle difference between kitman and tawriya.

We have to remember that Islamic law over the centuries has generated innumerable fanatics who are not barbarians but who are afflicted with an extreme form of OCD (Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder) in this, and other respects, in cultivating a jungle of semantic layers and distinctions concerning nearly everything in life—from bathroom hygiene, to dietary rules, to the circumstances of “lawful” killing, to the methods of beheading, to the complex determination of who is an enemy to be hated and/or killed, to the complexities of when and where it’s okay and not okay to have incestual sex; etc. etc. ad Islamonauseam.

I.e., Muslim clerics and scholars are not brute barbarians, but dangerous fanatics afflicted with various psychological disorders such as OCD, ADD, autism, idiot savantism, schizophrenia, sociopathy, psychopathy, pneumopathy, etc. We could partially explain this with the prevalence of incest in Islamic culture, over time breeding people with mental disorders; but that somehow doesn’t fully explain the phenomenon to me. Something darker, and deeper than mere biology and biochemistry, is going on in this regard.

A glimpse of this serpentine jungle of obsessive fanaticism I just stumbled upon, when Googling “kitman tawriya” (most of the few results were to Ibrahim’s essay here and on Frontpage) and finding a snippet of a scholarly article on Islamic history (the typographical problems were in the original):

…lying, such techniques of speech (kitman, ta’rıd, ilghaz, tawriya, ta’miya, ¯ ¯ ¯ Ë™ talbıs etc…)

You see, that list not only distinguishes “kitman” from “tawriya”, it also alludes to other distinct forms—ta’rid, ilghaz, ta’miya, and a fourth term for which the software program, unable to render the symbols, apparently had to provide dashes, probably because it was in Arabic script.

Of course, the more important and broader lesson to be learned here is that our fight against Muslims should not depend upon learning the thousands of details of the jungle of terms which their psychosis has over centuries cultivated; but rather to pronounce the whole sordid enterprise Islam as a deadly madness whose believers and enablers have to be stopped from endangering our societies. When we have time in between our far more important and multifarious efforts at stopping Muslims from endangering our societies—and certainly after we have succeeded with a measure of success—then it would be appropriate to spend (or waste) one’s time palpating the throbbing, pulsating complex of intestines manifesting the disease of Islam in all its amazing diversity.

* * * * *

And finally, as a postscript, I would call the reader's attention to this Google search page, where may be found a few old articles on Jihad Watch about the amusing-if-it-weren’t-so-deadly phenomenon in Islamic culture of “taqiyya about taqiyya”.

Monday, September 01, 2008

Stealth Taqiyya: Uncover, then surgically detach.




The term “stealth taqiyya” may seem to be a redundancy, but what I am getting at is a particular type of taqiyya that is doubly clever.
Contrasted with ordinary taqiyya, by which a Muslim pretends to be nice and tolerant and makes claims that Islam is nice and tolerant, the practitioner of
stealth taqiyya goes further:

He begins by apparently conceding, or even going the extra mile to actually uncover, the seamy underside of Islam, its dark side. Then, deftly and cleverly, he uses his concession (or his uncovering) as a tool by which to surgically detach the dark side from Islam itself. This is far more effective than ordinary taqiyya, especially in a context where more and more Infidels are becoming suspicious of Muslims, and hunger for some unvarnished truth-telling about their growing suspicion of something deeply, and broadly, wrong with Islam. In this context, the stealth taqiyyist with one hand satisfies the Infidel’s hunger for truth—and then, with the left hand, uses the Infidel’s satisfaction to subtly, even subliminally, reinforce the Myth of the Moderate Muslim Majority. The reinforcement achieved will be that much more effective when the taqiyyist has offered some tasty morsels first—morsels that have the temporary appearance of indicting Islam—rather than simply smiling and denying that there is anything wrong with Islam at all, as the ordinary taqiyyist does.

The Muslim reporter for the recent installment of the Undercover Mosque Dispatch out of the U.K. is, it is eminently reasonable to conclude, a stealth taqiyyist. While the benefits of this Undercover Mosque report are obvious—not only in uncovering the murderous hatred, intolerance and xenophobia in Islam, but also in uncovering it at a mosque (the large mosque at Regent’s Park in London) that was supposedly “moderate” and devoted to “interfaith” seminars—there are two things wrong with it which reveal its stealth taqiyya modus operandi:

1) The reporter herself—a Muslim who goes by the pseudonym “Sara Hassan”—weaves into her report of the seamy, dark underside of the mosque which she infiltrated the claim that “most Muslims” are not at all like the “fundamentalist” Muslims she documented. She buttresses that claim with another claim, that male preachers she saw in another part of that mosque were preaching “moderate” content. However, she gives zero evidence for these claims. While she documents in detail the “extremism” of the objectionable sermons, she gives zero details about the supposedly “moderate” sermons. And note that the “moderate” sermons were conducted by males, by which most everyone would subliminally conclude that they were the more dominant part of that mosque’s activity. Sara Hassan thus weaves into her report the Myth of the Moderate Muslim Majority, and her own identity as one such “moderate” Muslim—indeed, one courageous enough to go out on this limb of infiltrating a Muslim mosque!—adds ostensible credibility to it.

2) Closely related to #1 is the frequent allusion in the report to the “Saudis” and “Wahhabis”—subliminally reinforcing in the reader and viewer that the problem here is Saudi “Wahhabism”, rather than Islam itself. When she claims there were “moderate” sermons by male imams, she makes a point of saying they were “Egyptian”—hence, not Saudi.

Conclusion:

If Sara Hassan is doing taqiyya, it is quite a clever form of it: In effect what she is doing is satisfying the hunger that is growing more and more among Infidels for some unvarnished truth about Islamic extremism—so she provides a hot and scandalous example of it in this project, the Undercover Mosque report. However, part and parcel with these tasty morsels for the hungering Infidel comes a “package”—namely, that the extremism you see here represents a “hijacking” of true Islam, and only reflects a small minority. Thus the Myth of the Moderate Muslim Majority is reinforced—ingeniously using damning evidence of the dark and seamy underside!—rather than undermined.

The danger with reinforcing that Myth has the following effect:

It will serve (insofar as Western Infidels are gullible to it, and most seem to be) to bracket out the vast majority of Muslims from suspicion, thus allowing untold numbers among them to continue to infiltrate our West, either to continue to implement generalized stealth jihad in its various forms (not the least of which is the sheer demographic presence of multitudes of Muslims among us), or worse yet—to network in various webs of passive enabling and active support of terrorist cells.

As long as the Infidel consumer digests the substance of the Undercover Mosque reports and reject Sara Hassan’s clever packaging, it constitutes an enormous boost for the War of Ideas portion of our larger rally to defend our West. Unfortunately, since PC MC remains dominant and mainstream, it is more likely that a majority of Westerners will swallow the whole thing—including the edible, sugarcoated packaging.

Imagine George Bush, only one of the more famous Believers in the Myth of the Muslim Majority, watching the report. At the end of his viewing, were he asked for his two cents, he would undoubtedly say something like:

“These are radical extremists, and they are a problem in our societies, but they are only a tiny minority who are trying to hijack the great and noble Religion of Peace, Islam. They are twisting the religion of the vast majority of peaceful Muslims, who are all moms and dads just like the rest of us!”

Moral of the Story:

No Muslim can be trusted
—not even the seemingly benign Muslim, and not even the one who seems willing to concede certain ugly data about certain Muslims.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Misunderstanding Taqiyya














We, in the still beleaguered minority of autodidacts learning the full horror of Islam, all know generally speaking that
taqiyya is an Islamic concept which means, approximately:

Deceiving the non-Muslim in order to advance Islam in situations where Islam cannot be advanced through frank warfare.

A misunderstanding persists, however, among many of us aforementioned autodidacts; and this misunderstanding, I suspect, has its source in the asymptotic tendency to ascribe human psychology and human motivations to Muslims (where "human", whether the user of the term knows it or not, denotes a complex of Western qualities, among them foremost the historical feat, achieved uniquely and magnificently -- though, naturally nevertheless, imperfectly -- by the West, of transcending tribalism toward the philosophical and socio-political ideal of universalism).


Briefly put, the misunderstanding of taqiyya manifests itself as imputing to the Muslim a self-awareness of wrongdoing. Muslims, however, do not believe they are pursuing wrong. They sincerely, if psychopathologically, believe they are pursuing right. Their efforts at taqiyya, then, are equally sincere. The way that many (if not most) in the still inchoate anti-Islam movement seem to portray Muslims who practice taqiyya, one would think they are cackling mischievous demons who know they are evil and yet still revel in it. There may be some Muslims who are truly demonic in this way, though I tend to think that such a demonism confutes the crucial point of Satan's invention of Islam: Satan's genius in fabricating Islam consists precisely in being able to possess masses of people with the conviction that they are on the side of the angels (not the fallen ones) even as they simultaneously pursue every objective and every deed of God's original enemy. This masterfully ingenious trick, then, would collapse were Muslims indeed simple Satanists.

Ironically, this mistaken demonization of Muslims is consanguineous with the humanization of Muslims -- equally mistaken: the humanization of self-awareness of evil. The further darkness of psychopathology will help us to better understand the Muslim mind: How can it be that a person could genuinely, sincerely, in good conscience, enable and enact ideas and deeds of Islam which a sane person recognizes are grotesquely and ghoulishly evil? The answer to that rhetorical question lies in the darkness of psychopathology.

This approach has another advantage as well, and it is a critical one in terms of understanding the nature of our enemy during our time when Muslims for the first time in history are reviving and advancing Islam through a preponderance of taqiyya -- albeit in tandem with terrorism -- rather than through frankly military means. This model of psychopathology also explains all those millions of seemingly nice and peaceful Muslims out there who seem to be not following Islam (if by Islam we mean the one and only Islam of supremacist hatred and violent subjugation). The standard explanation -- even by otherwise tough-minded anti-Islam analysts and civilians -- for these seeming millions is that they are either "ignorant of their own Islam" or they are secularly "lax" and thus apparently consciously ignoring their own Islam for the most part even while continuing to remain "cultural Muslims" or "Muslims-for-identification-purposes-only". These latter types are also conjectured to be too afraid of their more Islamic brethren to come out of the apostate closet.

Given the mountain of evidence, however, indicating that Islamic culture and psychology is uniquely fanatical and cohesive, there is perhaps a better explanation for these hundreds of millions of seemingly nice and peaceful Muslims: they are psychopathic liars. They know perfectly well that their Islamic tradition is based on supremacist hatred and violent subjugation -- from the very beginning enshrined in the words and deeds of Mohammed and throughout history into the hot present with Muslim mujahideen trying to advance on every front around the world of its bloody borders, from the Philippines to Morocco, from India to England, from Russia to America -- with differences only in style, where in more regressive backwaters (e.g., the Philippines, Thailand, Sudan, Afghanistan, Chechnya, etc.) a more brazen guerilla effort is employed, while in more formidably advances societies (Europe, America) a subtler strategy is necessary, combining punctuations of terror attacks with a broad-based stealth jihad that requires taqiyya through and through.

It is eminently reasonable for us to err on the side of assuming that all Muslims know this perfectly well, are proud of it, and are helping in one way or another to enable it, but will lie about their knowledge when they think the naked truth would hurt the cause. But they do not lie out of shame for the truth, as though they were humans on a par with us who must surely see how evil and preposterous and monstrous their beliefs are. No: rather, they are lying to protect the truth, which they believe, sincerely in their heart of psychopathic hearts, is the summum bonum.

Once we in the still-inchoate anti-Islam movement realize this coherently, it will help to disabuse the movement of its subsidiary hope-cum-project to save us from the problem of Islam by saving Muslims from Islam, as though a sufficient number of the 1.2 billion Muslims out there will jump ship because they can be shamed by the truth of their own Islam of which, it is hypothesized, they remain strangely ignorant or in oh-so-human denial out of embarrassment.

The truth is grimmer than that, and we are advocating a reckless letting down of our guard when we imagine it to be rosier than it is.

Monday, July 06, 2015

Better Cops

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/41GDKATRW3L.jpg

The Better Cop has been developed to improve upon the Good Cop in the Good Cop/Bad Cop ploy.

In terms of the Stealth Jihad, the "Good Mo" (Good Cop) pretends that Islam is all sugar & spice and everything nice, and that, as a Good Muslim supporting that fantasy Islam, he or she represents the norm which has nothing to do with the Tiny Minority of Extremists -- the "Bad Mos" (Bad Cops).

Just as in the Good Cop/Bad Cop game, where the two cops are working in collusion but pretending not to, the violent & hateful Muslims wreak their havoc or spout their hateful rhetoric, while the Moderate Muslims step forward to assure the anxious Infidel that Islam is "a religion of peace" and is "against terrorism" and that most Muslims are not extremists.

As Muslims have been spiralling out of control in the nearly 15 years derailing from September 11, 2001, this game has shown slight signs here and there of straining credibility.  Hence the increased need to trot out a new and improved Good Cop:  the Better Cop -- a Muslim who feels our pain, doncha know, and goes further in applying the blade of criticism for deeper cuts into the problem of Islam, knowing that the TMOE meme (Tiny Minority of Extremists) is beginning to wear thin by now (at least on the edges of the Mainstream).

It's still the same game -- but it's played to a specific audience: the warier members of the Counter-Jihad.  It's a way of infiltrating the Counter-Jihad.  Zuhdi Jasser and Maajid Nawaz are perhaps the most famous of this type (the former apparently fooling Frank Gaffney, the latter fooling Sam Harris).

Back in 2008, I wrote an essay called Stealth Taqiyya -- not necessarily a redundancy, as I explain there.  One quote in particular from that essay zeroes in like a laser to the point of today's essay:

...what I am getting at is a particular type of taqiyya that is doubly clever.
 

Contrasted with ordinary taqiyya, by which a Muslim pretends to be nice and tolerant and makes claims that Islam is nice and tolerant, the practitioner of stealth taqiyya goes further:

He begins by apparently conceding, or even going the extra mile to actually uncover, the seamy underside of Islam, its dark side. Then, deftly and cleverly, he uses his concession (or his uncovering) as a tool by which to surgically detach the dark side from Islam itself. 


Over the past couple of years, I have noticed this type pop up more and more; but, unfortunately, other than an occasional essay, I haven't kept close tabs on them enough to formulate an analysis.  The first one that came to my attention was the "reformer" Bassam Tibi who, as I recall, even enjoyed a stint as a partner of Jihad Watch, warmly embraced by Robert Spencer.  An old essay on Jihad Watch from 2006 by Wolfgang Bruno describes Tibi saying all the right things that would appeal to those desperate to believe there are Muslims who want reform:

Meanwhile, the German-Syrian scholar Bassam Tibi, a Muslim reformist, is warning the West against wishful thinking in its “dialogue” with Muslims. “The dialogue is not proceeding well because of the two-facedness of most Muslim interlocutors on the one hand and the gullibility of well-meaning Western idealists on the other.”

More recently there was, for example, a Muslima named "Eilnyah" who wrote an open letter to the Great Defender of Muslims, Ben Affleck, in which she expressed the desire of herself and "those of us" for "reform" of the Unreformable Islam, and claimed that "[m]ost Muslims choose to interpret scripture in a peaceful way..."  Then there was Hamel Abdel-Samad, who wrote an open letter in Germany sort of addressed to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, in which he sounds many unusual, seemingly refreshing notes sure to seduce the more suspicious among us -- such as "Whoever lives here [i.e., Germany] must take on German values!" and expressing his change of mind over years to learn to appreciate satire and humor as a way of challenging his Islamic rigidity.  And more, which one will glean from his letter.  Sounds great, doesn't it?  Only problem, he's still a Muslim, and as such he reveres Allah, Muhammad, the Koran, and Islam.  For more specifics, see my comment about him.  Then there was Muslim professor Reza Varjavand, about whom I wrote an essay back in 2014.

Hopefully, I will try to do some more concerted analysis of various representatives of this subtype in ensuing months, and will record my efforts in subsequent essays.

Today's essay features just one of many -- both the Better Cop and the gull who seems fooled by them:  Anooshe Mushtaq, a Muslima who writes commentary for various publications about the problem of Islam, and whose pics show a nice, personably secularized persona.  About her, Counter-Jihad analyst Mark Durie writes:

...it is a hopeful sign that some Muslims, such as Anooshe Mushtaq, have been willing to explore the Islamic character of the Islamic State...

And what does Anooshe say?  After a few paragraphs of the obligatory Better Cop rhetoric that apparently soothes the likes of Mark Durie as sweet taqiyya in his ears, about how dire the problem of extremism is in the Muslim world and how it finds receptive resonance among religious Muslims, she makes sure to assure the reader that:

The vast majority of Muslims, nationally and internationally, don’t support terrorist organisations or their extreme views. 

Then she follows that with the requisite equivalency-cum-tu-quoque spasm:

However, there are people in all religions who take it further than others. Radicalisation is not a new trend. With or without the internet, it has been present in all religions throughout history.

Once she has made sure to establish the Affleck Doctrine (that "the vast majority of Muslims just wanna have a sandwich"), she's back to acknowledging the metastasizing, systemic problem, nevertheless, of extremism pullulating out of the Muslim world and spilling over into our world:

...we first need to understand why some Muslims are more susceptible to radicalisation, which seems to be spreading like a plague.

Um... yeah.

Sure, Mark Durie is ostensibly correct that Anooshe directly alludes to the Religion factor (i.e., the Islam factor) in explaining the appeal of ISIS to Muslims.  That's certainly an improvement on the explanations that ignore the solidly and richly Islamic character of the ISIS ideology.  However, true to the Better Cop tactic, she's only doing that to suck the Counter-Jihad Kafir in, while with the other side of her mouth she's ready to contextualize that Religion as extremist; thus:

Islamic State follows the Wahhabi sect of Islam...  an ultra-ortho­dox sect that insists on a literal interpretation of the Koran and a literal implementation of its teachings... Strict Wahhabis believe all those who don’t practise their form of Islam are infidels and enemies.

Notice the sleight-of-hand there, implying that what Wahhabis are doing is not normative Islam, and thus distinguishing it from what inspires the "vast majority of Muslims".  Her way of explaining why this non-normative, unrepresentative "sect" of Islam is having so much broad appeal among Muslims, and why this appeal is growing by leaps and bounds, thus has to unfold into tortured rhetoric and logic -- essentially disentangling (or, rather, entangling) two convoluted entrails intertwined with each other: one putatively benign, the other a growing global cancer.

Even granted the best case scenario, her thesis begs the question why such a horridlyy thorny problem is happening at all.  The logic she (and all the TMOE Memers) assiduously avoids is that the "plague" spewing out of the Muslim world leads to the reasonable inference that there is something horribly wrong with the swamp whence it originates.  From there, a more informed investigation and appraisal of the history of Islam confirms that the source (mainstream Islam) is the reason for the outbursts and bouts (ISIS, Boko Haram, Al Shabaab, Al Nusra, Sudan, Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda, Taliban, etc. ad Islamonauseam) which we keep seeing boiling over from the global cauldron of the Muslim world undergoing a global revival.

Monday, April 10, 2017

Sisi, ISIS: The dyslexic counter-jihad

https://desertdiaries.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/scrabble-arabic1.jpg

Naturally, I've seen many comments and remarks over the years within the Counter-Jihad Mainstream indicating that they actually believe a Muslim can be a Muslim all his life, and hail from a thoroughly Muslim country teeming with Islamic extremism (i.e., teeming with normal, baseline, mainstream Islam), and yet somehow be a "moderate".

All a Muslim has to do, apparently, is say the right things -- whisper sweet taqiyya in our ears -- and we gush like a schoolgirl and accept them at their word.  This process of deception -- and gullibility -- of course is far worse in the broader Western Mainstream, besotted as it is with PC MC; but my point is that it still occurs all too often, in various ways, even within the Counter-Jihad.  Which is why I call it the "Counter-Jihad Mainstream".

So, along came Egyptian military man and politician, Al-Sisi, in the wake of the "Arab Spring" turmoil in Egypt, ousting and replacing the Bad Cop Egyptian Leader, Morsi; and because Al-Sisi knows how to up the game to fool the warier in the West who are beginning to weary of the standard-issue Good Cop routine so many Muslims still deploy, many in the Counter-Jihad swooned.  I've seen disturbing signs that, for example, someone in the Counter-Jihad as bright even as Stephen Coughlin will turn around and talk as though he actually trusts Al-Sisi to be telling the truth, rather than taqiyya, when he affects moderation and feels our pain about "Islamist extremism".  Meanwhile, Robert Spencer, as usual, dances his dance in between trusting Al-Sisi and being skeptical.

Thus we have a report on Jihad Watch on Al-Sisi vowing to fight the extremists in his country, Egypt, after the horrific terror attacks against two churches occurred this week.  The reliably soft analyst on Spencer's team, Christine Williams, notes:

Sisi has mastered the gift of words, but apparently not action. 

And she proceeds to detail evidence that violence and hatred by Muslims against Christians has continued in Egypt, even under Sisi's rule.  But this should surprise no one, least of all in the Counter-Jihad.  That is, if the rule of thumb in the Counter-Jihad were to "trust no Muslim no matter what", instead of wasting our time searching around for evidence to show that a given Muslim does not deserve our trust.

Virtually the only person in the Counter-Jihad not taken in by Al-Sisi, it seems, is Andrew Bostom.  Four articles he wrote about Al-Sisi indicate that once again, a rational prejudice against Muslims qua Muslims is the way to go.  Merely by linking those articles here and now, I cannot avoid getting sucked into the "logic of vetting" -- which assumes that there is some reliable way to determine whether a given Muslim is, or is not, trustworthy.  My citation of Bostom here is not meant to try to prove Al-Sisi is a lying Muslim (i.e., an ordinary Muslim), since I don't believe one should have to even try to go through that exercise.

All I can hope for, as I continue re-arranging deck chairs on the Titanic here, is that readers in the Counter-Jihad will wean themselves away from the baby steps of milk & sugar pablum (i.e., needing evidence to prove a given Muslim is not to be trusted), to a more radical framework: rational prejudice against all Muslims.

Andrew Bostom's four articles on Egyptian General Abdel Fattah al-Sisi:

Al-Sisi’s 2006 Mini-Thesis Obtained by a Judicial Watch Freedom of Information Act Request (Albeit Some Hours After It Mysteriously Appeared Online at Foreign Policy)

Why Egyptian Putschist General Al-Sisi’s Anti-Secular U.S. Army War College Thesis Matters

Sisi Is Just Another Caliphate-Idealizing Apologist For Islam Whose In-Actions Speak Louder Than His Hollow Words

Taqiyya Theater? General al-Sisi’s August 2013 Wash Post Interview vs. His 2006 US Army War College Thesis 

The reliable analyst, Chris Logan over at Logan's Warning, has also seen through Al-Sisi.  Funny how so many in the Counter-Jihad can't adjust their brains with the simple principle in mind, trust no Muslim, no matter what he says.

Over two years ago, Logan penned a useful essay on the matter.  He begins with an incisive observation, articulating the relevant key to the whole matter:

All it takes is for a Muslim to say something non-Muslims want to hear, and many in the non-Muslim community come running in support. If one of them says Islam does not condone terrorism, or that Islam will reform they are mistakenly paraded around as the “savior” of the free world.

Logan goes on to note certain Muslims who fit this bill; though Logan doesn't seem to have refined the analysis into a taxonomy of types of deceitful Muslim, which I have analyzed at length in several essays revolving around the "Better Cop" phenomenon.  Indeed, one Muslim noted by Logan in that essay is one of the classic Better Cop Muslims par excellence out there -- Zuhdi Jasser.  And again, Logan is one of the precious few in the Counter-Jihad who is not fooled by Jasser.

Logan then turns to Al-Sisi, and notes dismayingly how even Pam Geller (a loyal partner of Robert Spencer's over the years, right up to the present) was suckered by his Better Taqiyya:

Today’s “moderate” Muslim rage is all about the President of Egypt Al Sisi, and I know she has done some excellent work with her transit ads, but of all people Pamela Geller should have known better.

Logan quotes some of her gushing statements about Al-Sisi:

Egypt’s President Sisi: A Titan For Freedom in the Islamic World Calls for Reformation of Islam 

Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi gave an extraordinary, groundbreaking speech on Islam on New Year’s day.

And so forth.

Sisi, ISIS; however you spell it, it's all the same.

Saturday, June 04, 2016

What does it take to seduce a Counter-Jihadist?

http://img.odometer.com/slides/2/4/8/7/5/1/2487510929/1b18d17e6e70eaf886f7fcabce040457aae60a5f.png

The "Better Cop" Muslims aren't really trying to fool the Western Mainstream; their target is the Counter-Jihad.

As activist Muslims must have realized years ago, the Western Mainstream is relatively easy to fool, since, as Useful Idiots, they are so anxious to please Muslims.  Indeed, often Muslims don't even need to lift a little finger, for PC MCs, unwittingly and witlessly, do most of their pro-Islam propaganda for them.

The Counter-Jihad, however, presents more of a challenge.  And since it has shown signs -- albeit still glacial -- of growing, indicating a slow -- albeit achingly slow -- tectonic shift of the West wising up to Islam, many Muslims apparently have realized they better try to infiltrate it in order to subvert it.  Just in case.

And while the standard-issue, garden-variety "Good Cop" Muslim has proven to be perfectly workable to fool the Western Mainstream most of the time (since merely repeating such mantras as that "Islam is peace" and "most Muslims are nice people and believe in democracy" work like a charm to fool the anxious-to-please Western Mainstream), obviously the Counter-Jihad isn't going to fall for that.

So, today's essay speculatively probes the question, how would a Muslim taqiyyist up his game and become a "Better Cop" -- a better used car salesman of the monstrous Lemon of Islam, with a spiffier suit and a snazzier tie and an oilier sales pitch -- in order to sell that disastrously toxic & dangerous heap to a consumer who should know better?

The first answer is that those in the Counter-Jihad Mainstream (CJM) are not, as most of them seem to imagine themselves, immune from the wiles of taqiyya -- it just takes cleverer taqiyya to get into their pants, so to speak.  And the reason for this is that most in the CJM are not, as they seem to imagine themselves, perfectly immune from PC MC.   People in the Counter-Jihad didn't come from Neptune; they grew out of the same cultural soil as the rest of their Westerners around them, the vast majority of whom are PC MC in varying degrees because PC MC is just that dominantly fashionable as a worldview throughout the West.  It stands to reason, then, that a number of Counter-Jihadists would have retained at least traces of PC MC (a phenomenon I have analyzed before as "asymptotic").

The dynamic is probably as close to what elementary logic would dictate:  The higher the degree of PC MC in the heart & mind of the Counter-Jihadist (i.e., the more asymptotic he is), the more likely he'll be vulnerable to the soft-soaping bull of the Better Cop.

However, the Better Cop's job isn't done yet; he's not going to win over a Counter-Jihadist simply by standing there and smiling.  He does at least have to go through the motions of some sales pitch.

And what does that sales pitch entail?

First, he has to go farther than his "Good Cop" brothers & sisters -- he has to actually criticize Islam, to show he's a cut above the Mohammedan norm.  He has to "feel our pain" about all the problems that Islam has been causing the world.  For you see, a Counter-Jihadist is not going to fall for the ordinary TMOE meme (the meme that claims that the violent problems perpetrated by various Muslims around the world are due only to a Tiny Minority of Extremists whose motives & inspiration have nothing to do with the normative Islam of the vast majority of Muslims out there who just wanna have a pita sandwich).

So the Better Cop has to take the bull by the horns (or the camel by the ears) and go after Islam itself -- in effect, to concede that, yes, there are elements of Islam that are motivating and inspiring terrorism around the world, in the form of "Wahhabist" and "Salafist" "extremism".

Hidden in that seemingly refreshing concession, however, are two clever ploys:

1) Seeming to be anti-Islam, but really protecting Islam.  

A subtle sleight-of-hand whereby the Better Cop lures his gull with the "big print giveth, and the small print taketh away".  I.e., with one hand, so to speak, he gives the appearance of criticizing Islam itself, while with the other hand he protects Islam by contrasting it with "Wahhabist" and "Salafist" "extremism" which is supposedly not what mainstream Islam is all about.  The better the Better Cop is at his parlor trick, the more he is able to juggle this equivocation -- with slick rhetoric making his audience think he's making deep cuts of criticism into Islam itself, while at the same time magnifying the influence and power of the Tiny Minority of Extremists who are inspired by Islam, but yet still aren't practicing "true" Islam.  In a sense, what is really going on is that the Better Cop is selling the same TMOE meme as are the Good Cops, only the "MOE" (Minority of Extremists) may be granted grudgingly to be larger than "Tiny".

2)  Making sure to protect the (vast?) majority of Muslims from (too much) criticism. 

One way the Better Cop does this is by carefully focusing all our criticism on the Islam of the Extremists, with subtle locutions calculated to give the impression that it's not "true" Islam.  Although they won't bluntly say, as Good Cops do, that the terrorists are only "hijacking" and "twisting" Islam, their logic leads to that conclusion.  The other way is by another feat of equivocation, whereby the Minority of Extremists vacillates from being so small, it's just a marginal problem which all societies have -- to being described in terms that make it seem like a big problem indeed, so as to foster the optical illusion of being tantamount to a description of Islam itself.  When the Better Cop is talented, as Maajid Nawaz is, for example, he can go back and forth with ease like an acrobat, all the while telegraphing with subtle cues that this does not reflect on "most Muslims".

One thing the Better Cops never do is talk much, if at all, about the problem of taqiyya; though I wouldn't put it past the defter ones to "get out in front of that one" too, by "owning" the problem in the full light of their critique -- then perhaps deflecting from the devastating implications of it (namely, that one cannot trust any Muslim at all) by trying to make it sound like "we" can "usually" detect taqiyya if "we" have educated ourselves enough in the tactics of the "Salafists".  Again, on the one hand rhetorically magnifying the problem in order to assure the listener that he, the Better Cop, appreciates the full gravity of the situation; while on the other hand concluding with a facile solution to it that carefully avoids the aforementioned devastating implication.

Most of all -- and this is something that dawned on me when I read and watched the Sam Harris / Maajid Nawaz collaboration -- the Better Cop offers us Counter-Jihadists a way out of the horrible dilemma which our growing knowledge of the horror of Islam has put us in:  Over the increasingly alarming post-911 years, we are slowly realizing that the problem is Islam itself and all Muslims, but because of residues of PC MC in his heart & mind, he's too afraid to really think that thought crime through.  Along comes the Better Cop to help him out of this quandary.  Through his understanding rhetoric that feels our pain, he soothes us into relaxing into the prospect that here, in the flesh, we see a real reformer Muslim (or at least the viable possibility of one).  Then when the Better Cop throws in plenty of secular Western mannerisms and phrases, and cracks a few casual jokes (even a couple of "groaners" to show us how human he is), we feel deep down an enormous relief to have found a Muslim who veritably personifies the Moderate Muslim we had been, all along, hoping against hope existed somewhere (even if long ago we had given up on that term in our bitterly jaded cynicism).  Now we can be anti-Islam and at the same time be friends with a personable Muslim -- and likely many more where he came from --- who agrees with us and likes us!  For, there must be many more Muslims like him out there in the wide world -- after all, he tells us so, and he wouldn't lie to us, would he...?

Further Reading:

Essays on the Better Cops


Tuesday, December 13, 2016

The two Mainstreams dovetail -- part 3

http://www.getrichslowly.org/images/IKEA.jpg

The longtime Jihad Watch commenter (and member of the "Rabbit Pack" there), one "PRCS", figured prominently in part 1 and part 2 because I was using him as an example.

From my years on Jihad Watch comments (before I was banned yet again a few months ago), PRCS became well known to me to epitomize the Counter-Jihad Softy who affects an oh-so tough stance on Islam.

When, back in October of last year, under the nickname "voegelinian", I tried to illuminate some sense out of his comments in a Jihad Watch comments field, and I pointed out the excruciatingly relevant problem of our inability to determine, adequately for our ongoing safety, which Muslims are dangerous and which are harmless (conceding that the latter category exists), including Muslims anywhere on Allah's green earth (including America, for Muslims once they are in America do not suddenly become magically delicious and moderate), PRCS took my breath away with this response:

PRCS quoted me, when I argued that because of this inability of ours (which stems in great part from dealing rationally with Islamic taqiyya) we need to assume that the problem “…obviously translates to All Muslims.”

Then he replied:
 
No, it does not. You do recall the “All American Muslim” television program, eh?

PRCS, a stalwart veteran of the Counter-Jihad and stout critic of Islam, actually typed that out with a straight face.  He actually sincerely believes the deceitful propaganda of shows like All American Muslim.

And if that isn't bad enough, only one of the other Jihad Watch regulars, one "gravenimage", including the best among them, the "Rabbit Pack", bothered to take him to task for this egregious naiveté (whether she did so adequately, we shall find out in part 4).

Anyway, par for the course, the busiest beaver among the Rabbit Pack ("Angemon"), proceeded to attack me instead, popping up like an Energizer Bunny whenever I was busy responding to PRCS.  And meanwhile, gravenimage ignored Angemon's attacks on me, and only deigned to respond when I parenthetically included her name amongst the others whom I was critiquing along with PRCS.

Such as:

  • PRCS says
    October 16, 2015 at 9:45 pm

    [quoting me:] "When or where did I ever say I don't know that?"

    -- which was my response to PRCS when he said:  "You know full well that the dreaded A word is an unprovable opinion" (the dreaded A word being, "All Muslims" about which I've written many times) -- PRCS went on to say:

    As you really can't read other people's minds, and if you really do know that, then stop making references to it.

    And I proceeded to unpack the problem:

    This reaction by PRCS is not addressing my response, in which I argued that —

    “The point is that assumptions contrary to the A word are also unprovable opinions. bolstered only by a reliance upon superficial data and a studious avoidance of the problem of taqiyya.”

    — which means that those who are asserting the contrary which presumes a viable existence of harmless Muslims are also assuming mind-reading. A problem of 1.3 billion people belonging to a culture that endangers us in horrific ways (along with the problem of taqiyya) cannot avoid the mind-reading assumption. The point then pivots to which side we err on: caution in order to protect our society, or generosity in order to avoid being “bigoted”. The Counter-Jihad Softies (PRCS, Mirren, Angemon, gravenminage, Wellington, et al.) consistently and obtusely (not to mention outrageously given the mountains of data they are aware of reported here on Jihad Watch over the years) defend the latter.
Angemon proceeded to attack me two more times, and gravenimage continued to ignore his attacks on me (as she always did over months and months, ignoring literally hundreds of attacks by her friend and peer, Angemon, on my position on the problem of Islam).  Meanwhile, she took the time out to chide me for mentioning her and the rest of her peers as being more or less Softies.

Speaking of gravenimage, I mentioned that she was the only one of the Jihad Watch regulars who bothered to critique PRCS.  But did her responses to PRCS really get to the heart of the matter -- our inability to tell the difference between harmless and dangerous Muslims?

We shall find out in Part 4.



Wednesday, June 22, 2016

Kitman or Tawriya...?

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiJIsi1wbtB01iw5zbkbwDwv-2Tntn_eV1HI8gYhB-uvSVvQFW46XHBPOSfmaCOK9SM3XbgHFOiiFScn4K18LkjuKII8DEyZIVi2OmGV3t2yVwZzoT7V3IhmIFlkYzFUZPoz5u2/s1600/truth1.jpg

The Attorney General of the United States of America, Loretta Lynch, is one of a small handful of people who have the highest obligation to tell the truth under law.

The American legal phrase used in courts across the nation to swear in testimony is refers to:

The truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

This seemingly redundant phrase is masterful because if followed conscientiously, would prevent the person from engaging in two of the main forms of Islamic deception -- kitman and tawriya (subtypes of taqiyya).  Kitman is telling half the truth, but leaving out a crucial portion of the truth.  Tawriya is is deceit by ambiguity.

When we look at our Attorney General's pronouncement upon the Orlando terror attack by the Muslim ghazi Omar Mateen, it's difficult to tell which form of taqiyya it fits best:

"The most effective response to terror is compassion, unity and love."

The Attorney General is correct:  From the standpoint of Islamic Jihad, the most effective response to the "terror" of the Great Satan (the West, with America at its vanguard) is when their enemies fail to fight back, and rather think they must indulge in the Kumbaya virtues of compassion, unity and love.  Such a response by us will indeed most effectively help Muslims conquer our societies.  So the Attorney General was speaking the truth.  The truth from the perspective of Islamic victory, that is.

In a way this is both deception by speaking half the truth, and a manipulation of the semantics of rhetoric through ambiguity: thus a combination of kitman and tawriya. 

Do I think Attorney General Lynch is actually doing taqiyya?  Or is she one of the thousands of influential Useful Idiots the West suffers under?  It's becoming increasingly difficult to maintain the latter view, but in the interest of Ockham's Razor, I still do:  the behavior of our "Elites" over the past 15 years in response to the metastasizing danger of Islam can be explained by a pervading culture of politically correct multi-culturalism (PC MC), so there's no need to reach for the more elaborate and implausibly diabolical explanation of some sort of conspiracy.  This principle is reinforced by the fact that innumerable non-Elites throughout the West evidently share varying degrees of that same PC MC perspective.

Tuesday, December 01, 2015

Hesperado's Law

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/images/reviews/190/1348680360_1.jpg

My law is sort of modeled after those unofficial, unscientific Laws or Rules listed among the eponymous Laws which a Wikipedia page catalogues (most of them are scientific laws) -- such as Benford's Law of Controversy:  "Passion is inversely proportional to the amount of real information available" or Betteridge's Law of Headlines:  "Any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word 'no' ".  And of course most everyone knows Murphy's Law:  "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong."

My law may not be as cheeky as these, though it is meant to be provocatively informative; much like Auster's First Law of Majority/Minority Relations (about which I've written):

“The worse any designated minority or alien group behaves in a liberal society, the bigger become the lies of Political Correctness in covering up for that group.”

While Auster seemed to distribute his deployment of his Law almost indiscriminately (pun intended) among blacks and Muslims, my essay on this clarified the important differences those two demographics present which in turn highlight how, when PC MC is dealing with Muslims, it ratchets up the logic of that Law to an even higher degree of torsion, so to speak, than when it deals with blacks.

Readers of my blog over the years may recall that back in the summer of 2011, I developed four "Hesperado's Laws", so if I were being strict about this, I'd have to call today's law the "Fifth" one; but thank Allah I'm not strict.  So what the hell, call this Hesperado's Law.  While those other "Laws" are important, this one to me really gets to the heart of the matter.

At any rate, without further jihadoo, here it is:

Whenever a Muslim individual or group behaves in a manner that seems benign, instead of accepting that at face value, reverse engineer it to figure out why the Muslim individual or group would be doing that, given that the Islam that inspires & guides them is the opposite of benign.

What this Law calls for is not merely the general epiphany we have had in the Counter-Jihad that any given Muslim when seeming to be moderate is actually doing taqiyya -- it is calling for us to come up with a reverse-engineering explanation for how that taqiyya works in that specific context.

The principle undergirding this Law would be the following:

When it comes to Muslims, do not give them the benefit of the doubt, do not presume them innocent until proven guilty, but rather always assume the worst.

Note:  Is this "Law" and its principle illegal under Western laws (including the American Constitution)?  It would be, if actually translated into any action (state or private) that mistreated any Muslims without due process.  However, it's not meant to be a prescription for behavior; it's meant on the level of the war of ideas, as a meme to shake our PC MC out of its irrational presumption that Islam is not a blueprint for violent sedition and deceptive espionage.  I can understand people thinking it's not a useful meme, because it might well provoke reactions of recoil, even in the Counter-Jihad (but certainly in the mainstream), since it seems to be too harsh.  If someone can think of a kinder, gentler way to persuade fellow Westerners of the gravity of the devolving, metastasizing situation, factoring in the devastating problem of taqiyya, I'm all ears.

Further Reading:
Reverse Engineer

Wednesday, February 15, 2017

Uzay Bulut: A new addition to my blogroll, or just another "Better Cop"...?

Image result for police coffee

According to the brief bio on one of the venues Bulut writes for, Arutz Sheva, Bulut was "born a Muslim".  Whether she has since become an apostate, however, they leave unanswered.  Meanwhile, her bio at Gatestone Institute is even less helpful:

Uzay Bulut is a Turkish journalist based in Ankara. She holds a master's degree in media and cultural studies at Ankara's Middle East Technical University.

However, the byline of one of her articles at Gatestone Instintute published back in 2015 offers a tantalizing bit more, but still no definitive cigar:

Uzay Bulut, born and raised a Muslim, is a Turkish journalist based in Ankara.

I.e., she could be "born and raised a Muslim" yet now be an apostate.  This is not trivial quibble: it cuts to the heart of whether we ought to trust her.

From a brief sampling, the list of her articles at Gatestone Institute appears to be a good general source of the problem of Islam in Turkey (and, occasionally, elsewhere in the Muslim world and in the West).  I haven't yet detected any asymptotic memes in her writing; however, if she is a Muslim, one would have to assume she's doing "Better Cop" stealth jihad.  This doesn't mean that her articles aren't useful, since part of the strategy of the "Better Cop" is to tell at least half the truth.  And if one is judicious and has a keen eye for the various modes of taqiyya, one need not dispense with the fruit of her labors.

Ah, I see here, in an article she wrote in 2015 -- The Most Inexcusable Crime in the Muslim World -- she extolls Malala Yousefzai, about whom even many in the Counter-Jihad Mainstream seem appropriately suspicious.  Otherwise, the article is quite useful.

And lo and behold, in another article -- The Difference between Islam and Islamism? -- she expresses an apparent (and exquisite) fusion of the asymptotic meme with taqiyya, speaking of "...the thin, fragile line between Islam and Islamism -- or between progressive Islam and radical Islam."

On the other hand, in yet another article -- Sexual Slavery: "Nothing to do with Islam?" -- Bulut consistently refers to "Islam" as the culprit of her analysis, not "Islamism".

Finally, in her article -- The West's Dangerous Enchantment with Islam -- she runs through some typical PC MC memes.  Let's see how she answers a couple of them:

"What you are seeing is not the real Islam; Islam has been hijacked."

The problem with this view is that Islam actually does teach that a woman is worth less than a man. Many teachings in Islam are misogynous -- from wearing veils; requiring four male witness to prove rape; issues of inheritance; court testimony; rules of marriage; rules of divorce and remarriage; a man's "right" to marry up to four women and then beat them, and so on.

Though she's only focusing on the treatment of women in Islam, elsewhere she has indicted Islam for being supremacist, martial, fanatical, and xenophobic.

Her answer to another PC MC shibboleth, however, is not as good:

"Not all Muslims are the same. There are good and bad Muslims, just as there are good and bad people in all religions."

First of all, thank you very much for this genius discovery. But how can it help reduce the Islamic violence around the world?

Of course it is true that there are many good Muslims, whose values do not follow Islamic teachings verbatim, but also include humanitarian values. They do not wage war on other religions or try to bring them under submission to Islam. In the eyes of jihadis or Islamists, however, who live by the harshest interpretation of most doctrinaire Islamic teachings, such a quality makes them "bad Muslims."

Her answer completely ignores the problem of stealth jihad, and its attendant problems, taqiyya, the False Moderate, and the Hijra emigration into the Dar-al-Harb in preparation for an epochal conquest of the West.  These factors explain innumerable Muslims who while appearing to be harmless, are actually enabling the Jihad; and they do so in a variety of modes, including the mere appearance of being a harmless Muslim -- which, in turn, includes the cleverest stealth jihadist of them all: the Better Cop who "feels our pain" about how bad Islam is, thus lulling us into a vague acquiescence to the fait accompli of continued Muslim penetration into our societies, in the rose-colored hope that most of them are -- or will become after living in the West long enough -- "lax" or "secular" or "ignorant of their own Islam" or "MINOs" ("Muslims in Name Only"), if not even as cool as Uzay Bulut and all of her fellow Better Cops are (Maajid Nawaz, Zuhdi Jasser, Asra Nomani, Tawfik Hamed, Irshad Manji, etc.).

Conclusion:

To answer my titular question, I guess I will do both: put Uzay Bulut on my blogroll, and add her to my list of Better Cops.

Monday, November 03, 2008

He Said, She Said







Glossary: taqiyya = lying in order to protect Islam.

In my previous long essay on Obama, I listed 17 worrisome associations Obama has had with Muslims and pro-Islam bedfellows. For more on this, see this article by Daniel Pipes.

A
column today by Cinnamon Stillwell reveals yet another: Edward Said, a professor in comparative literature at Columbia university who is more famously remembered (he died in 2003) for his 1978 book Orientalism, which crystallized emblematically all the deleterious strands of politically correct multi-culturalism and has helped enormously in ensuing years to further the academic and pop culture propagation—and propaganda—of politically correct multi-culturalism.

One of Obama’s worrisome associations I did list was with Rashid Khalidi, a virulently anti-Israel pro-Palestinian Muslim who now holds, at the same university at which Said taught, the—guess what—Edward Said Chair, an academic position whose dubious donors have donated four million dollars to create. A casual Googling of one of the Middle Eastern names on that list of donors yields the following:

Yusef Abu Khadra, who is on record expressing this blandly insidious taqiyya:

“Islam is a capitalist religion. it believes in free enterprise,” maintains Yusef Abu Khadra of Investcorp, the Bahrain investment bank that purchased New York retailer Saks Fifth Avenue. But the religion of the Prophet is also imbued with a strong sense of social justice. “You can make money but you must give some of it to the poor,” he explains. “Zakat the Islamic tithe] must be given to beneficiaries who are not relatives. Rich Muslims have an obligation to help other Muslims-across borders, across cultures, across languages.”

I invite the reader to do the same for other names on that list.

A photo (the very one I have put at the top of this essay) has been circulating the Internet, of a dinner for the Arab-American community in Chicago in 1998. In that photo we see Obama and his wife Michelle seated at a table, and the man with whom Obama is conversing in rapt attention is Edward Said, seated next to his wife, Mariam Said.

For more on Edward Said, see this article by Hugh Fitzgerald. I quote two particularly illuminating paragraphs from that article:

Fitzgerald mentions Ibn Warraq’s book Defending the West: A Response to Edward Said.

That book deals with how Edward Said, and his acolytes and worshippers and epigones, have so crudely misconceived and misrepresented the nature of the Western world and its art, its literature, its scholarship, its openness to what Said and friends like to call “the Other” and to then claim for that “Other” a long history of victimisation.

Then Fitzgerald more broadly discusses Said's pseudo-scholarship of the West and the Middle East:

Said was dismembered in feline fashion by Bernard Lewis in “The Question of 'Orientalism'.” Last year Robert Irwin’s “For Lust of Knowledge,” a refutation of Said, essentially a book-length footnote to Lewis’ article, appeared. Irwin demonstrates conclusively what many (but not Christopher Hitchens) knew: that Said’s misrepresentations of several centuries of distinguished Orientalists was comical in the things he got wrong, the things he left out, his inability to comprehend disinterested curiosity or disinterested scholarship, so foreign were they to the mind and even imagination of Edward Said. Everything that he could get wrong, Edward Said got wrong.

Given what we know about Obama and all his associations with Muslims and pro-Islam apologists who themselves also get everything wrong, it is likely that whatever Obama learned from Edward Said was uncritically swallowed whole. In the years since 1998, what was uncritically swallowed whole by Obama has been digested, and if tomorrow he wins the election, will be in the following years under his Presidency excreted in powerfully toxic doses into the bloodstream of the Body Politic; though it is also likely that Obama, a master at smooth dissembling, will be able to make such excrement seem sweet and nutritious—to those millions of Americans, that is, who themselves have been sufficiently deformed by PC MC.

A pro-Palestinian Muslim blogger, one Ali Abunimah (who was part of the Arab-American dinner in 1998 discussed above), recounts a meeting he had with Obama in 2004 that might shed light on a little taqiyya Obama himself is adept at practicing:

The last time I spoke to Obama was in the winter of 2004 at a gathering in Chicago’s Hyde Park neighborhood. He was in the midst of a primary campaign to secure the Democratic nomination for the United States Senate seat he now occupies. But at that time polls showed him trailing.

As he came in from the cold and took off his coat, I went up to greet him. He responded warmly, and volunteered, “Hey, I'm sorry I haven’t said more about Palestine right now, but we are in a tough primary race. I'm hoping when things calm down I can be more up front.” He referred to my activism, including columns I was contributing to the The Chicago Tribune critical of Israeli and US policy, “Keep up the good work!”

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Hesperado: B.I.P. (Blog in Peace)











I was banned from Jihad Watch approximately five days ago. Fuller details
here.

A couple of days ago, a commenter on Jihad Watch, "Denise", was nice enough to post a comment on Jihad Watch which I had drafted -- a bittersweetly droll, but not in the least merely rhetorical, request:

Hi gravenimage, Wellington, dumbledoresarmy, Eastview, traeh, duh_swami, Courreges, demsci, Susanp -- Hesperado is wondering from beyond the grave if you remember him, and if you do, would you say a few words at his memorial service in memory of his passing?

This comment appeared at about 11 pm on September 28, on a respectably large and active
comments thread. It is now nearly 48 hours later, the evening of September 30. Only two of those named bothered to respond, and their responses were rather pathetic demonstrations of toeing the line:

I remember Hesperado, I burn a candle for him every night, but I have no comment on his recent demise on JW...Sometimes you need to be careful about what you say or how you say it...or run the risk of deletion or banning...There is a dedication to free speech, but there are limits...If it is an opinion or outburst that reflects poorly on JW or staff, and can be used as a missile by those who would smear, it is deleted...Repeat offenders get banned...This is as it should be... duh_swami

A few hours later, The commenter "demsci" wrote:


I respect and miss Hesp, his intelligence, his analysis, his unbelievable depth and logic also and it came as a shock to me also to see him banned. Very unfortunate. But I see it as his fault, especially with his brains, not to respect the clear boundaries of Jihad Watch, which he did cross, with his epiphany that Muslims were no[t] humans.

To the latter, Denise responded:


Thank you for writing, demsci, but I don't consider the boundaries regarding this particular comment as clear as you find them to be. In fact I have read similar comments (similar to the one that Hesp made) from other posters over the years, but they never resulted in deletion or banning; so I am not entirely sure what "clear boundaries" you are referring to. ... Remember, he was banned without warning, but only later learned why. His "epiphany" comment wasn't even a repeat offense, since the offense didn't become known until AFTER the fact - until after he was banned. I have stated many times over the years that muslims can be "heartless & soulless" in some of my comments, which is similar in nature to what Hesp had written, and yet that remark never raises an eyebrow. I mean which is more egregious, my comment or his? They seem the same to me. I find some of the rules a bit confusing ...

What I found interesting was a later
comment by Marisol, asking a Muslim commenter, Yusef YK, to substantiate his apparent claim that some Jihad Watch commenter wrote that all Muslims "need to be mulched". (To date, he has not responded to Marisol). Marisol then explained:

You know our policy, and you know how disingenuous you are to ascribe such sentiments to anyone who works for Jihad Watch. We delete genocidal and/or racist comments the moment we see them, or when they are brought to our attention.

Well, the two comments of mine that caused Marisol to ban me contained neither genocidal nor racist sentiments. I invite the reader to read my
two comments, and demonstrate either genocidal or racist import in them. Unlike the commenter alleged by Yusef YK to have said that all Muslims "need to be mulched", nowhere in my comments did I advocate any action at all against Muslims. I have before on Jihad Watch comments (and here on my blog) advocated total deportation, but I have never advocated genocide, ethnic cleansing, or lynching.

An even more egregious (if subtler) example of unfairness practiced by Spencer & Marisol is indicated by the aforementioned Jihad Watch reader Denise, who informs me about the fiercely dogged defender of Spencer, nicknamed "awake" (for a display of awake's emotionalism and irrationality, I invite the reader to click on "Jihad Watch Watch" on the upper right of my blog here and peruse various comments sections where awake and I engaged in copious disputes). Denise claims (and I have no reason to doubt her) that awake posted a comment on Jihad Watch last month attacking me:

He then ended his rant last month by making some vile comment, which included calling you an f-er, and then about an hour later that word was scrubbed from his comment. And the sentence was left hanging, so it now reads something like this: "You are such a" ...

I.e., the loyal friend of Jihad Watch, awake (aka "Mike Slumber"), posts an offensive comment on Jihad Watch, and instead of being punished or having the comment yanked -- or even simply being admonished -- Marisol does him the gentle favor of taking some spit and Windex and cleaning up some of the unsightly smudges he left. Why didn't Marisol do me the same favor of simply airbrushing out my "epiphany" that so offended her? The answer, it seems, is that Marisol and Spencer (of one mind) had it in for me, and were just waiting for anything coming vaguely close to a pretext in any of my comments.


On a related note, I find it rich that the Jihad Watch commenter nicknamed "B" (one wonders if he chose that single letter to make it difficult for people to search for his comments in the archives), who in the thread in which I was banned made a point of defending Marisol's decision (and in the process, of mischaracterizing my supposed crime), more recently made a statement not that far from the one I made that so offended Marisol; arguably "getting close to the territory" of my statement, as Marisol would say.

First, here is what "B" wrote in defense of Marisol:

I agree and I think anyone lurking these boards or posting need to learn what Taqiyya means and how to spot it being used among Muslims. This will make you more assured of your dealings with Muslims and less afraid to engage Muslims in your own personal life. The goal with sites like Jihad Watch is to educate people about Islam, specifically the dangerous portions of Islam. Are all Muslims dangerous? No. Learning to recognize a Muslim who could be a valuable partner in the community and learning to trust them (but understanding Taqiyya and knowing what to watch for) is advantageous for all of us. Many Muslims in the American community have acted as informants to let Law enforcements know when something is going wrong or when Jihadists are present in the community or Mosque. They wouldn't be doing this if they felt like they were going to be stabbed in the back by us. When some people on this board make a blanket statement about "Muslims" without first identifying which Muslims you are referring to, I cringe. If you are doing this, you need to continue to educate yourself about Islam and Muslims. The information provided on Jihad Watch is there for a reason. Use it. I am against Jihadists Muslims or Islamic Supremacists. These are the people who embrace the violent parts of Islam and follow Jihad in all its variant forms (both peaceful and violent). I am not against peaceful Muslims who simply want to live and provide for their families. I am friends with many of them, and more specifically know many Iranians. Their wish is to practice religious Islam but not the political. Some Muslims I know are only Muslims in name only (MINO, if you will.) So please be careful on this distinction about Muslims.

Shortly thereafter, "B" added:


For people who makes a blanket statement like "f*** all muslims, they deserve (whatever punishment that person thinks of)...

I never said "f*** all muslims" nor anything close to that. I described my process over a long time of emotions and thoughts based upon the horrible atrocities perpetrated, countenanced and enabled by Muslims all over the world, and on that basis made an argument for a conclusion that "Muslims are not human" -- careful to add that my conclusion was not meant to be an ontological pronouncement. But carefully nuanced argument -- and consequently, respectful counter-argument -- seems to be beyond both the civilians at Jihad Watch, and the staff there.


To continue with "B" --

... Be more reasoned about who you are targeting in the Muslim community. Not all Muslims are Jihadists. To those Muslims we need to get their support in either reforming Islam or abandon it. Do you want to identify the enemy and deal with them? Or are you just going to tell all Muslims to f*** off and leave the US?

In that same thread, "B" then responded to the acutely apt question from Denise --

"can YOU tell the difference between a truly safe muslim and a dangerous one?"


-- and wrote:


You can never be too sure about anything. Even the best of the best have been fooled. Do you remember when the CIA station in Afghanistan was bombed by a guy who turned out to be a double agent? Yes, even they were fooled and I would consider CIA to be the best at figuring it out. You can learn to spot a Muslim employing Taqiyya and this will help you in your community to combat those local CAIR representatives. Those people are going to make all of us look bad by claiming Islamaphobia. Knowing the Quran well inside and out, knowing the contradictions will allow you to face those people in letters to the editors or if you are bold enough, to stand up in any speech they give to the community and show others their contradictions. Are all Muslims bad or using Taqiyya? No. Not all of them are doing this. Some are just like you and I, earning a living and caring for their family. Some probably are unaware of what the Quran really says and tells them to do. Should you lump all of them in with the Jihadist? No, because then you definitely won't save them if there ever is a chance to do so.

Okay, now that we have all that tediously asymptotic B material under our belt, here is the
more recent statement he made that so amused me, in light of the above:

One must also remember that Muslims share the concept of the Ummah. In prostrating the idea of the Ummah, they become duty bound to follow the commands of the Quran. Those commands supersede even the loyalty of ones own family. They command that if your brother, mother or father is not following the Koran properly, then one should deal with their own family members properly. When I read about the Ummah and Muslims, It really reminds me of the Borg in the Star Trek Next Generation TV series. The Borg all think with one mind and follow the same rules and laws. Their duty is to assimilate all life into the "collective".

Gee, that sounds like "B" is condemning all Muslims as a mindless monolithic block of an evil force. He better watch out, or Marisol will cast him into the outer darkness, and he'll be gnashing his teeth like me, too.

Then, another similarly quasi-schizo Jihad Watch reader named "mike ryan" responded to this statement by "B" thusly:


Well said, B!

And yet, this same "mike ryan" just a few comments above B's comment had just gotten finished trotting out the tired exculpation of Muslims and the artificial distinction between Muslims and Islam:

... I am not anti-Muslim. I am against the teachings of Islam that lead to extremism, violence, hatred, and bigotry against followers of other religions. I am opposed to the oppression of Muslims by their co-religionists in the name of "Allah" or any other nomenclature with which you or anyone else would care to justify their or our oppression.

And concluded with the only logical conclusion based on such sentimentalist crap -- a rhetorical question divorced from the grimly horrible reality of Muslims:


My question is this: When will Muslims begin to take stock of the very real suffering that these teachings and those who follow them inflict upon the rest of humanity?

Anyone who has been reading Jihad Watch with any degree of attention and regularity would be disabused of even contemplating such a question, even rhetorically. We should possess the grim answer, which would lead us reasonably to assume that Muslims will never change -- at least not in numbers sufficient for the safety of our societies -- and that they will remain as fanatically obsessed with hating and dominating us as they have unremittingly done so for the last 1,400 years.

Conclusion:

Very few readers of Jihad Watch -- even counting those who have been reading it for years and who should thus know better -- have really digested the full horror of Islam, and the full horror of Muslims. As a consequence, they have to find ways, to assuage their liberal anxiety, to avoid the logical consequence which Islam and Muslims force upon us. And when someone like me comes along articulating that logical conclusion, they recoil, and let Marisol clean up.