The Better Cop has been developed to improve upon the Good Cop in the
Good Cop/Bad Cop ploy.
In terms of the Stealth Jihad, the "Good Mo" (Good Cop) pretends that Islam is all sugar & spice and everything nice, and that, as a Good Muslim supporting that fantasy Islam, he or she represents the norm which has nothing to do with the Tiny Minority of Extremists -- the "Bad Mos" (Bad Cops).
Just as in the Good Cop/Bad Cop game, where the two cops are working in collusion but pretending not to, the violent & hateful Muslims wreak their havoc or spout their hateful rhetoric, while the Moderate Muslims step forward to assure the anxious Infidel that Islam is "a religion of peace" and is "against terrorism" and that most Muslims are not extremists.
As Muslims have been spiralling out of control in the nearly 15 years derailing from September 11, 2001, this game has shown slight signs here and there of straining credibility. Hence the increased need to trot out a new and improved Good Cop: the
Better Cop -- a Muslim who feels our pain, doncha know, and goes further in applying the blade of criticism for deeper cuts into the problem of Islam, knowing that the TMOE meme (Tiny Minority of Extremists) is beginning to wear thin by now (at least on the edges of the Mainstream).
It's still the same game -- but it's played to a specific audience: the warier members of the Counter-Jihad. It's a way of infiltrating the Counter-Jihad. Zuhdi Jasser and Maajid Nawaz are perhaps the most famous of this type (the former apparently
fooling Frank Gaffney, the latter
fooling Sam Harris).
Back in 2008, I wrote an essay called
Stealth Taqiyya -- not necessarily a redundancy, as I explain there. One quote in particular from that essay zeroes in like a laser to the point of today's essay:
...what I am getting at is a particular type of taqiyya that is doubly clever.
Contrasted
with ordinary taqiyya, by which a Muslim pretends to be nice and
tolerant and makes claims that Islam is nice and tolerant, the
practitioner of stealth taqiyya goes further:
He
begins by apparently conceding, or even going the extra mile to
actually uncover, the seamy underside of Islam, its dark side. Then,
deftly and cleverly, he uses his concession (or his uncovering) as a
tool by which to surgically detach the dark side from Islam itself.
Over the past couple of years, I have noticed this type pop up more and more; but, unfortunately, other than an
occasional essay, I haven't kept close tabs on them enough to formulate an analysis. The first one that came to my attention was the "reformer" Bassam Tibi who, as I recall, even enjoyed a stint as a partner of Jihad Watch, warmly embraced by Robert Spencer. An
old essay on Jihad Watch from 2006 by Wolfgang Bruno describes Tibi saying all the right things that would appeal to those desperate to believe there are Muslims who want reform:
Meanwhile, the German-Syrian scholar Bassam Tibi, a Muslim reformist, is warning the West against wishful thinking in its
“dialogue” with Muslims. “The dialogue is not proceeding well because
of the two-facedness of most Muslim interlocutors on the one hand and
the gullibility of well-meaning Western idealists on the other.”
More recently there was, for example, a Muslima named "Eilnyah" who wrote an
open letter to the Great Defender of Muslims, Ben Affleck, in which she expressed the desire of herself and "those of us" for "reform" of the Unreformable Islam, and claimed that "[m]ost Muslims choose to interpret scripture in
a peaceful way..." Then there was Hamel Abdel-Samad, who wrote an
open letter in Germany sort of addressed to German Chancellor Angela Merkel, in which he sounds many unusual, seemingly refreshing notes sure to seduce the more suspicious among us -- such as "Whoever lives here [i.e., Germany] must take on German values!" and expressing his change of mind over years to learn to appreciate satire and humor as a way of challenging his Islamic rigidity. And more, which one will glean from his letter. Sounds great, doesn't it? Only problem, he's still a Muslim, and as such he reveres Allah, Muhammad, the Koran, and Islam. For more specifics, see
my comment about him. Then there was Muslim professor Reza Varjavand, about whom I wrote
an essay back in 2014.
Hopefully, I will try to do some more concerted analysis of various representatives of this subtype in ensuing months, and will record my efforts in subsequent essays.
Today's essay features just one of many -- both the Better Cop and the gull who seems fooled by them: Anooshe Mushtaq, a Muslima who writes commentary for various publications about the problem of Islam, and whose pics show a nice, personably secularized persona. About her, Counter-Jihad analyst Mark Durie
writes:
...it is a hopeful sign that some Muslims, such as Anooshe Mushtaq, have
been willing to explore the Islamic character of the Islamic State...
And what does Anooshe say? After a few paragraphs of the obligatory Better Cop rhetoric that apparently soothes the likes of Mark Durie as sweet taqiyya in his ears, about how dire the problem of extremism is in the Muslim world and how it finds receptive resonance among religious Muslims, she makes sure to
assure the reader that:
The vast majority of Muslims, nationally and internationally, don’t
support terrorist organisations or their extreme views.
Then she follows that with the requisite equivalency-cum-tu-quoque spasm:
However, there
are people in all religions who take it further than others.
Radicalisation is not a new trend. With or without the internet, it has
been present in all religions throughout history.
Once she has made sure to establish the Affleck Doctrine (that "the vast majority of Muslims just wanna have a sandwich"), she's back to acknowledging the metastasizing, systemic problem, nevertheless, of extremism pullulating out of the Muslim world and spilling over into our world:
...we first need to understand why some Muslims are more susceptible to radicalisation, which seems to be spreading like a plague.
Um... yeah.
Sure, Mark Durie is ostensibly correct that Anooshe directly alludes to the Religion factor (i.e., the Islam factor) in explaining the appeal of ISIS to Muslims. That's certainly an improvement on the explanations that ignore the solidly and richly Islamic character of the ISIS ideology. However, true to the Better Cop tactic, she's only doing that to suck the Counter-Jihad Kafir in, while with the other side of her mouth she's ready to contextualize that Religion as extremist; thus:
Islamic State follows the Wahhabi sect of Islam... an ultra-orthodox sect that insists on a literal
interpretation of the Koran and a literal implementation of its
teachings... Strict Wahhabis believe all those who don’t practise their form of Islam are infidels and enemies.
Notice the sleight-of-hand there, implying that what Wahhabis are doing is not normative Islam, and thus distinguishing it from what inspires the "vast majority of Muslims". Her way of explaining why this non-normative, unrepresentative "sect" of Islam is having so much broad appeal among Muslims, and why this appeal is growing by leaps and bounds, thus has to unfold into tortured rhetoric and logic -- essentially disentangling (or, rather, entangling) two convoluted entrails intertwined with each other: one putatively benign, the other a growing global cancer.
Even granted the best case scenario, her thesis begs the question why such a horridlyy thorny problem is happening at all. The logic she (and all the TMOE Memers) assiduously avoids is that the "plague" spewing out of the Muslim world leads to the reasonable inference that there is something horribly wrong with the swamp whence it originates. From there, a more informed investigation and appraisal of the history of Islam confirms that the source (mainstream Islam) is the reason for the outbursts and bouts (ISIS, Boko Haram, Al Shabaab, Al Nusra, Sudan, Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda, Taliban, etc. ad Islamonauseam) which we keep seeing boiling over from the global cauldron of the Muslim world undergoing a global revival.
As I wrote when I first heard of just one of these (tawriya, from a Raymond Ibrahim article on Jihad Watch), back in 2012:
This tawriya seems to be not a separate type of deceit from taqiyya, but a categorical distinction: i.e., taqiyya is the category of the virtue and pragmatic efficacy of deceit in general, which may be crudely simplistic or artfully clever; while tawriya would be the methodology of how to do it — or at least one methodology. It resembles clever sophistry, whereas there are cruder ways to lie, as they used to say, “baldly”.
For example, if someone declares “I don’t have a penny in my pocket,” most listeners will assume the speaker has no money on him -- though he might have dollar bills, just literally no pennies.
The cruder, balder, more blatant form of lying about this would be to say simply, “I have no money”, meanwhile one’s pockets are bulging with 100-dollar bills. Many Muslims have shown themselves to be fully capable of doing this cruder form, and fully willing to do so -- and why not, when there are so many gullible Guilty White Westerns around them anxiously willing to give a Brown Person the benefit of the doubt?
The difference between the cruder form and the more artful form of tawriya would be the difference between what has been colorfully rendered as “lying through your teeth”, and the cleverer, more devilish (if not positively Satanic) form where the tongue becomes a cunning linguist of a snake to perform a perverse and abusive fellatio on its more or less unwilling victim (depending on his gullible naivety and desperation to believe in the wiles of the Moderate Muslim...).
We have to remember that Islamic law over the centuries has generated innumerable fanatics who are not barbarians but who are afflicted with an extreme form of OCD (Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder) in this, and other respects, in cultivating a jungle of semantic layers and distinctions concerning nearly everything in life—from bathroom hygiene, to dietary rules, to the circumstances of “lawful” killing, to the methods of beheading, to the complex determination of who is an enemy to be hated and/or killed, to the complexities of when and where it’s okay and not okay to have incestual sex; etc. etc. ad Islamonauseam.
I.e., Muslim clerics and scholars are not brute barbarians, but dangerous fanatics afflicted with various psychological disorders such as OCD, ADD, autism, idiot savantism, schizophrenia, sociopathy, psychopathy, pneumopathy, etc. We could partially explain this with the prevalence of incest in Islamic culture, over time breeding people with mental disorders; but that somehow doesn’t fully explain the phenomenon to me. Something darker, and deeper than mere biology and biochemistry, is going on in this regard.
A glimpse of this serpentine jungle of obsessive fanaticism I just stumbled upon, when Googling “kitman tawriya” (most of the few results were to Ibrahim’s essay here and on Frontpage) and finding a snippet of a scholarly article on Islamic history (the typographical problems were in the original):
…lying, such techniques of speech (kitman, ta’rıd, ilghaz, tawriya, ta’miya, ¯ ¯ ¯ Ë™ talbıs etc…)
You see, that list not only distinguishes “kitman” from “tawriya”, it also alludes to other distinct forms—ta’rid, ilghaz, ta’miya, and a fourth term for which the software program, unable to render the symbols, apparently had to provide dashes, probably because it was in Arabic script.
Of course, the more important and broader lesson to be learned here is that our fight against Muslims should not depend upon learning the thousands of details of the jungle of terms which their psychosis has over centuries cultivated; but rather to pronounce the whole sordid enterprise Islam as a deadly madness whose believers and enablers have to be stopped from endangering our societies. When we have time in between our far more important and multifarious efforts at stopping Muslims from endangering our societies—and certainly after we have succeeded with a measure of success—then it would be appropriate to spend (or waste) one’s time palpating the throbbing, pulsating complex of intestines manifesting the disease of Islam in all its amazing diversity.
And finally, as a postscript, I would call the reader's attention to this Google search page, where may be found a few old articles on Jihad Watch about the amusing-if-it-weren’t-so-deadly phenomenon in Islamic culture of “taqiyya about taqiyya”.